| Beyond Images - Briefing 2   | 
                    Perspectives on the Arab-Israeli Conflict  | 
                   
                   
                    |  ISRAEL'S 
                      LAW OF RETURN - Fulfilling a Humanitarian Mission | 
                   
                   
                    London - 5 July 2002   
                          
                         | 
                    Click 
                      to Print  | 
                   
                 
                
                   
                    |   Statement 
                      "Israel's law of return 
                        is discriminatory because it gives Jews from anywhere 
                        in the world the right to live in Israel while Palestinians 
                        cannot enter the country".  | 
                   
                 
                The Law of Return is Israel's national immigration 
                  Law  
               
             
            
              -  
                
 
                   Israel is a sovereign nation and a member 
                    of the United Nations. It was re-established in 1948 as the 
                    national home of the Jewish people (see Beyond Images 
                    Briefing 1 - The Unbreakable Bond).  
                     
                     
                 
               
              -  
                
 
                   For thousands of years, the Jewish people 
                    had been scattered across the world, but Israel offered them 
                    the opportunity to escape persecution and build a new life. 
                    Following Israel's establishment, thousands of Jews entered 
                    the country, mostly refugees from the Arab world who were 
                    driven out of their countries of origin, without compensation. 
                     
                   
                 
               
              -  
                
 
                   Every country is entitled to enact its 
                    own immigration law, and for Israel it was a matter of the 
                    highest national priority that it offers a safe haven for 
                    Jewish refugees who wished to enter the country. 
                     
                   
                 
               
              -  
                
 
                   The Law of Return, enacted in 1950, fulfilled 
                    that objective. It is the national immigration law of the 
                    Jewish people. It is as legitimate and justifiable as the 
                    immigration law of any other country.  
                 
               
             
             
               
                 
                  The Law of Return has made possible the ingathering of millions 
                  of persecuted or dispersed Jews  
               
             
            
              -  
                
 
                   Millions of Jews have migrated to Israel 
                    under the Law of Return from countries as diverse as Yemen, 
                    Morocco, Russia, Argentina, Australia, the USA, India, Bosnia, 
                    France and Ethiopia.  
                     
                   
                 
               
              -  
                
 
                   Thousands of lives have been saved, and 
                    Jewish communities rescued from isolation and persecution, 
                    because of the availability of immigration. 
                 
               
             
             
               
                 
                  The Palestinians would need an equivalent to the Law 
                  of Return once they achieve self-rule  
               
             
            
              -  
                
 
                   Ironically, if and when the Palestinian 
                    people achieve self-determination, they would need the equivalent 
                    of such a law to govern the influx of Palestinians.  
                     
                   
                 
               
              -  
                
 
                   Such a law would entitle Palestinians living 
                    anywhere in the Arab world, Europe or for that matter anywhere 
                    else, to migrate to the new state. Needless to say, such a 
                    law would give priority rights of entry to Palestinian Arabs, 
                    over any other national or ethnic group.  
                     
                   
                 
               
              -  
                
 
                   No-one would think to suggest that such 
                    a Palestinian law was "discriminatory" for giving 
                    priority rights of entry to Palestinians.  
                     
                   
                 
               
              -  
                
 
                   It is an inherent part of any immigration 
                    law that it gives precedence to the nationals of the country 
                    in question.
                     
                   
                 
               
             
            
               
                It is the absence of peace and normalisation which prevent 
                Palestinians from returning 
             
            
              -  
                
 
                   Since 1948, there has never been peace 
                    between Israel and the Palestinians. For as long as that continues, 
                    Jews the world over will be able to continue to migrate to 
                    Israel, but Palestinians will not be able to migrate to the 
                    territories over which they aspire to have self-rule.  
                     
                   
                 
               
              -  
                
 
                   It is not Israeli "discrimination" 
                    which has created this situation, but the absence of a political 
                    solution to the Arab-Israeli conflict, addressing the right 
                    of return, compensation funds and resettlement programmes 
                    in a just and sustainable way.  
                     
                   
                 
               
              -  
                
 
                   These issues were raised in Israeli-Palestinians 
                    negotiations during 1999-2001 (which ultimately failed).  
                     
                   
                 
               
              -  
                
 
                   While Israel rejected an open-ended "right 
                    of return" by Palestinians into Israel, it made clear 
                    it would support an agreement by which any Palestinian could 
                    readily return to a future Palestinian self-rule entity. A 
                    'law of return' to the Palestinian state would be needed to 
                    achieve this. 
                     
                   
                 
               
             
            
            
              -  
                
 
                   There is nothing discriminatory about Israel's 
                    Law of Return. It has enabled Israel to fulfil a humanitarian 
                    mission by offering a home to Jews from around the world. 
                     
                   
                 
               
              -  
                
 
                   It is counter-productive for Israel's critics 
                    to condemn a law which the Palestinians will in due course 
                    need to emulate. 
                   
                 
               
             
             | 
         
        |