militant Islam, accepting Israel:
Muslim women speak out
Published: 10 May 2006
Briefing Number 173
Summary: This Briefing
highlights the outspoken condemnation of militant Islam
by certain Muslim women writers and professionals. The
Briefing, and the direct quotes included in it, is based
on an article by Israeli commentator Saul Singer, who
suggests that history will “save a spot” for
these Muslim women who “put their lives on the line”
in the “battle” against militant Islam.
Singer writes (Jerusalem Post, 24 March 2006):-
Since a single interview on Al-Jazeera on February 21 2006,
Wafa Sultan, a Syrian-born psychologist now
living in the US, has become an overnight sensation. The link
to the clip on www.memritv.org
has received over a million hits, and Sultan has been interviewed
by The New York Times, The Sunday Times, and Le Monde. Sultan,
in her original five-minute interview, became the Rosa Parks
of the global struggle against Jihad: the catalyst whose stubborn
courage marks a turning point.
“The clash we are witnessing around the world is not
a clash of civilisations”, Sultan said in that interview
“it is a clash between civilisations and backwardness….
between barbarity and rationality…. between human rights
on the one hand and the violation of these rights on the other,
between those who treat women like beasts, and those who treat
them like human beings…”
Then she went even further.
“The Jews have come from tragedy and forced the world
to respect them, “ she said, “with their knowledge,
not with their terror; with their work, not with their crying
“We have not seen a single Jew blow himself up in a German
restaurant…. Only the Muslims defend their beliefs by
burning down churches, killing people and destroying embassies….
The Muslims must ask themselves what they can do for humankind
before they demand that humankind respect them.”
Perhaps inspired by Sultan, on March 11 the Syrian poet Adonis
said on Dubai TV:
“When I look at the Arab world, with all its resources,
the capacities of Arab individuals, especially abroad –
you will find among them great philosophers, scientists, engineers
and doctors. In other words, the Arab… can excel –
but only outside his society. I have nothing against the individuals
– only against the institutions and the regimes….
We Arabs are in a phase of extinction, in the sense that we
have no creative presence in the world…” (translation
The taboo has been broken. It has become impossible to prevent
Arabs from questioning the mantra that has sustained oppressive
regimes for so long: both denying backwardness and blaming it
on America and on the Jews.
Perhaps the most striking and radical in this ‘Muslim
Spring’ of fresh thinking, however, was an op-ed in this
week’s New York Times by exiled Iranian author Irshad
“Like all Muslims, I look forward to the day when neither
the IDF jeep nor the wall is in Abu Dis. So will we tell the
self-appointed martyrs of Islam that… before the barrier
there was the bomber? And that the barrier can be dismantled,
but the bomber’s victims are gone forever?”
Manji is even more heretical to the Muslim ear than Sultan
because she not only defends Jews, but Israel, and not only
Israel, but the security fence.
Why did a Muslim battling militant Islamism defend Israel on
such a controversial topic? One might think the last thing someone
engaged in the debate over Islam would want would be to ‘discredit’
herself by association with Israel…..
[Singer comments here about a critique of Israel by two
….. My hunch is that Sultan and Manji felt they had to
go so far as defending Jews and Israel because they recognise
that it is impossible to fight the Islamist jihad without exposing
its Jew-hatred in an unapologetic manner. They realise that
we – Jews, Christian, and non-jihadi Muslims – are
in this together.
As Muslims, they understand that jihad is seamless. Christian
westerners are deluding themselves if they think that, by jettisoning
Israel, they will curb Islamic hatred, rather than simply whetting
This is not just a prediction, it’s history. For decades,
the West tolerated and even rewarded terrorism against Israel.
It was the PLO, not Bin Laden, who first proved that terrorism
does not delegitimise a cause but puts it on the map. In other
words, it works.
It was the teaching that terror works that brought 9/11, and
threatens more and larger 9/11s. Undoing this lesson is the
primary challenge of our age. And central to that challenge
is for the West to realise that its problem is not “blind”
support for Israel….. but the opposite: a failure to call
the Muslim world to account for its continuing violent refusal
to accept Israel’s right to exist.
The West is not too pro-Israel for its own interests: it is
not “pro-Israel” enough. The dynamic in which Palestinians
can attack Israel and create a “humanitarian crisis”
of their own suffering that will be blamed on Israel has yet
to be fully broken.
This is the logic Manji sought to expose when she blamed the
bomber, not the barrier – and by extension, the jihad,
not Israel’s existence.
Beyond Images comments: Women such as Sultan,
Adonis and Manji have been prepared to take a stand on militant
Islam, at risk to their lives. Supporters of Israel’s
rights should focus on those who deny Israel’s right to
exist, and highlight the fanaticism and intolerance of their